Apologetics Index: Information about cults, sects, movements, doctrines, apologetics and counter-cult ministry.  Also: daily religion news, articles on Christian life and ministry, editorials, daily cartoon.
Religion News Report
Archived News items about religious cults, sects, and alternative religions



Church of God Restoration beliefs at issue in case

Church beliefs at issue in case

A court hearing is this week for a couple who did not seek medical help for a baby who died.

The Press-Enterprise, Feb. 11, 2002
http://www.pe.com/ Off-site Link
church of god restoration, religion news report provides news of interest to those who work in Christian apologetics and countercult ministries.  It includes information about religious cults, sects, new religious movements, and related issues, such as religious freedom, religious tolerance, and cult crimes.


The recent seizure of a healthy infant boy from his parents' Rancho Cucamonga home marks the second time in six months authorities have taken children from members of an Inland-based church.

In Canada last summer, social workers took seven siblings from their parents, also members of the church, Canadian authorities said.

In both cases, investigators said the parents' religious beliefs put the children at risk.

Divine healing and corporal punishment of children are central tenets of the Church of God Restoration, a small but widely scattered sect based in Upland, say researchers and authorities in the United States and Canada. The church is believed to have about 400 members.

Agnes and Richard Wiebes' belief in divine healing contributed to the death of their 11-month-old daughter and may have been a factor in the stillbirths of two other children, investigators said. Their son was taken from them last month because they refused to cooperate when authorities tried to check on the newborn's welfare.

The Wiebes, charged last July in the death of their daughter, are free on bail while they await trial. A preliminary hearing in the manslaughter case is scheduled for Thursday.
[...]

The church is under the strict direction of its founder, Daniel Layne, according to authorities in Canada and within the San Bernardino County Sheriff's Department. Layne, in a 1984 autobiography, described himself as a prophet and recovering heroin addict.

The Wiebes' beliefs are heavily influenced by Layne, sheriff's Detective Leland Boldt said.

Members of Layne's church meet Sundays for prayer in a small, cream-colored building nestled in a quiet neighborhood of 1940s homes in Upland. The men dress in black suits. The women wear long skirts and buttoned-up blouses and pull their hair into tight buns.

"Essentially, Layne's followers seem to have abdicated much of their own ability to think critically and make independent decisions and instead defer to Mr. Layne," said Rick Ross, a nationally recognized cult expert who has researched the Church of God Restoration and written essays on Layne.
[...]

San Bernardino County coroner's officials first were called to the Wiebes' Deerbrook Street home in early July 1996, not long after the couple moved from Canada. Agnes Wiebe's full-term baby boy, Amos John, was born dead, according to the child's death report.

"I interviewed Agnes who was lying in bed," wrote Randy Emon, a deputy coroner at the time. "Agnes said she did not have any prenatal care."

Three years later, Deputy Coroner Andrew Avery described a similar scene after the Wiebes delivered a second stillborn boy, Michael Aaron, in their home in March 1999.

"They are members of the Church of God and do not believe in any medical intervention," Avery wrote. "Present at the scene were four other women from the church. They were present at the time of the delivery; however, no one was trained in midwife skills."

About 11 a.m. July 6, 2001, the Coroner's Department again was summoned to the Wiebes' ranch-style home. Hours earlier, paramedics had responded to reports that a baby had stopped breathing at the address, a coroner's report said.

Julia, the Wiebes' 11-month-old daughter, was dead. Agnes Wiebe said she had been lying on a mattress with Julia, who had had a fever for a week and three days earlier had suffered a seizure. The girl, she said, took one deep breath and stopped breathing, according to an autopsy report.

"The child had never seen a physician during her life, apparently because of her parents' religious beliefs," Deputy Coroner Jim Sedgwick wrote. "No immunizations had been administered."

Authorities said the baby died of meningitis, an inflammation of the membranes in the spinal cord or brain. Medical care neglect was listed as a contributing factor.

"Although this child died of a naturally occurring infection, i.e. meningitis, the death could have been prevented by routinely available medical treatment," wrote pathologist Steven Trenkle after he performed the autopsy. "Although the parents did not seek medical care because of personally held religious beliefs, their decision not to have the child evaluated or treated certainly contributed to this death."

The Wiebes were charged with manslaughter and willful cruelty to a child.

In January, sheriff's officials got a tip that the Wiebes had another child. Deputies went to the home to check on the newborn, but the Wiebes refused to answer questions or allow deputies to see the child. A warrant was obtained, and the boy was taken into protective custody.

The baby was moved last month to a foster family pending the outcome of custody hearings in county Juvenile Court. The hearings are not public.
[...]

Some of Layne's followers adopted a book, "Mommy, Daddy, We Would See Jesus," as a parenting guide, Bailey said.

The 190-page volume, written by a Tennessee pastor's wife in 1999, instructs parents, among other things, how to train their children.

"Just as there are certain techniques which work for dogs, so there are techniques for training children," the book says.

"I know of a 10-month-old who learned to lie quietly in his crib and go to sleep by himself without rocking -- after only two nights of training him to do so. But the mom had to be determined. She could not give into his crying, and had to use the switch on his little leg to make him believe she meant business."

Cathy Cimbalo, director of San Bernardino County Department of Childrens Services, said physical discipline is illegal only if it leaves marks or bruising on the child.

While not necessarily abuse, she said, the "use of an instrument on a child that young is inappropriate.

"I can't imagine a reason that a child that young could deserve that," she said.

That belief in corporal punishment caused an exodus of church members from Canada last year, according to Bailey, Tinsman and articles in the London Free Press.

Conflict in Canada

Last July, about the same time Julia Wiebe was dying, images of children being dragged from their home appeared on television news in Aylmer.

Seven children from 6 to 14 years, all from the same family, were removed by Canada's Child and Family Services agency because of the parents' belief in corporal punishment, Bailey said. The parents are part of Layne's church, he said.

The children were returned after the parents agreed to stop spanking them until a trial decides whether their discipline is too severe, Bailey said.

Layne has been quoted in the London Free Press and Canadian newspapers as saying that neither he nor his church prohibits the use of medicine.

Bailey said that, based on his investigations, church members are not encouraged to seek medical care.

"The company line is: 'We don't tell them not to use medicine, but faith healing is an important part of our beliefs,' " Bailey said. "The assumption, we have learned from past members, is: If you have to go to the doctor, your faith must not be that strong."
[...]

In the middle of one night last summer, more than 100 women and children belonging to Layne's group in Canada left their homes.

Taking all of their possessions, 28 mothers and roughly 80 children embarked on a journey that would take many of them from Ontario, Canada, to Ontario, Calif., Bailey said.
[...]

Some settled in Ohio and Indiana. Some church members, including Layne, moved west to San Bernardino County about three years ago. Though once Canadian residents, the Wiebes were not part of the group that left Canada, Bailey said.
[...more...]
Back To Top




More News:
» Religion News Blog carries the latest news about religious cults and sects, world religions, Christian denominations, televangelists, and related issues.
Back To Top



About this page:
Church of God Restoration beliefs at issue in case
Copyright: Original publisher. Material used under the ''fair use'' clause. More information
» Copyright and Linking Policy
» How to use this site